Midnight Stag has been one of my favorite scents for several years now. I love using the shaving soap, aftershave balm and when I saw it was available as a cologne, I had to buy it. Itâs a very masculine yet complex scent. At first itâs very strong, but after a while it mellows out with a nice smoky, musky smell. One word of advice is to use less than you would other colognes. A little bit goes a long way.